The question I just can’t answer
I’ve always found it hard to talk about emotions. Not because I don’t feel any, but because I don’t seem to be able to define them in ways others can relate to.
Take love as an example. If someone asked me how I loved them, how would I respond? I’d sit there – genuinely trying to answer – and probably wouldn’t be able to. Not because I didn’t love the person. Because the categories of love that came to mind wouldn’t correspond to anything I could find inside myself.
I’m autistic. And the way I experience emotions is binary.
Emotions are either there, or they aren’t.
Back to love: I don’t have a gradient that runs from love for the world to mild affection to friendship to romantic love. I have two categories: present or absent. And interestingly, some emotions have never been present at all. Hate, for example. I’ve looked for it in particular when I have felt wronged by others. It isn’t there.
For most of my life I assumed this was a flaw. Like I was missing some emotional equipment everyone else had been issued at birth.
Here’s what I’ve come to understand instead
The typical taxonomy of emotions – and of love specifically, with its friendly, romantic, platonic, parental, brotherly varieties – is not a natural feature of every human being’s experience.
The taxonomy of emotions is a social construct.
A map, built by and for a particular kind of mind, transmitted through a particular kind of social learning.
The neuroscientist Lisa Feldman Barrett makes a version of this very argument at the level of neuroscience. Her core claim – developed in her 2017 book How Emotions Are Made – is that emotions are not hardwired universal categories the brain simply reads off from the body. They are constructed. The brain uses concepts, learned through social experience and cultural transmission, to make meaning out of raw physiological signals. You don’t feel love and then label it. You feel something, and the concept of love – the version your particular culture handed you – shapes what that something becomes.
If the social learning that was supposed to transmit those concepts worked differently for you, you may have built a different architecture entirely. Not broken. Different.
Mine looks like this: emotions are either present or absent. When present, they’re total. The distinctions others want me to draw – is this friendship or something more, do you love me like a brother or a partner – don’t correspond to any internal differentiation I can find. And some of the categories on the standard map – hate, contempt, indifference – appear to be simply missing from my territory.
Different doesn’t mean wrong
I want to be careful here, because there’s a version of this that romanticizes the autistic experience in ways I find inaccurate. I’m not claiming my undifferentiated emotions are purer or more authentic than the taxonomized version. The distinctions neurotypical people draw between types of love, types of anger, types of grief, track something real about human experience.
Neurotypical framing of emotions isn’t arbitrary. But it's also not universal.
Cross-cultural research has documented significant variation in how emotions are categorized across different societies. The ancient Greek categories – eros, philia, storge, agape – map poorly onto many non-Western frameworks. The particular map most Western, neurotypical people carry is one map among many possible maps. It happens to be the dominant one in the culture I live in. That doesn’t make it the territory.
What I’m arguing is more modest: the map was built by and for a particular kind of mind. I have a different kind of mind. The result is not that I experience emotions incorrectly. The result is that I experience them without the map. And living without it turns out to be a surprisingly good vantage point from which to notice that it was always a map – not the territory it claims to represent.
How do you feel your emotions?
If you’ve never been able to explain how you feel – not because the feeling isn’t there, but because the available categories don’t fit – you might understand what I mean. And if you’ve never had that experience, I hope at least I’ve made it harder to assume that someone who can’t sort their emotions into the right boxes must have fewer emotions.
The boxes are not the emotions. The map is not the territory.
Sources
[1] Barrett, L F (2017). “How emotions are made: the secret life of the brain”. Pan.
